The following is an incomplete list of pastors that have served at ECPC - Most of this list was taken from "A Sketch of the History of Birmingham Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian church 1896-1898" compiled by Barry Anderson in 1989. Information for this list was also taken from "The History of Elliottsville Cumberland Presbyterian Church " by Lavada Harper, cleck of Session, 1940

• Rev Dave Young Wyatt-also served as the first pastor for Spring Creek CPC Church in Montevallo, AL- was one of Spring Creeks founding members
• Rev. L,F. Goodwin 1897
• Rev. J.H. Zwingle
• Rev. Eugene Lee
• Rev. L.B. Morgan
• Rev. J.W. Chesier
• Rev. J.M. Alexander
• Rev. A.C. Acton
• Rev. E.R. Knox
• Rev. J.D. McCain
• Rev. A. Doyle
• Rev. Tommy Dorsett
• Rev. S.G. Herring
• Rev. Mr. C.E. Bishop 1952-
• Rev. Joe Barlow
• Rev. Neal Morris
• Rev. Harold Hicks
• Rev. Beverly Johnson
• Rev. Mr. Roy Hall 1972-1976
• Rev. Mr. Terry Maynard 1976-1994
• Rev. O, Ray Howton 1995-1996
• Rev. Mr. Chris Joiner 1997-2003
• Assoc. Pastors Rev. Mr. Earl Goodwin & Rev. Mr. Tom Gillis 2003-1/2004
• Rev. Mr. Mark A. Davenport 1/2004-present